82.3k views
3 votes
Analyze the idea of narrowing of interests, oversimplification, and inadvertent failure, as discussed by Scott.

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

Scott's discussion on narrowing of interests, oversimplification, and inadvertent failure highlights the importance of focus in political proposals, the challenges of maintaining a precise scope in writing, and the collective issues in society that can lead to imbalanced political representation.

Step-by-step explanation:

When analyzing the concept of narrowing of interests, oversimplification, and inadvertent failure as discussed by Scott, we can understand these as issues that arise in the context of policy making and representation within the political system. Scott suggests that when attempting to tackle a proposal, focusing your topic is crucial because trying to address too broad of an issue can lead to insufficient evidence and an overreliance on generalities which result in a lack of depth in analysis. In the case of representing different interests in the political system, pluralist scholars like David Truman and Robert Dahl posit that the competition among diverse groups is beneficial for democracy, but this view is sometimes criticized for not accounting for economic bias and the unrealistic expectation that all groups have equal opportunity to be heard. Furthermore, developing writers often struggle with maintaining a precise scope, which can lead to extraneous information and detract from the clarity and effectiveness of their work. Additionally, the author emphasizes the importance of not strictly focusing on an author's intention, as it can limit one's own interpretive efforts and thoughtful analysis. Finally, in collective societal scenarios, if common shortcomings are prevalent, such as cynicism about the government's response to the needs of non-elites or economic bias in the interest group system, the voices of the more cognizant individuals may be overshadowed, leading to an imbalanced representation in the political process.

User RickJames
by
7.5k points