Final answer:
It is impossible to determine whether Paul is in violation of Article 11 without the full text and context of the article as well as a description of his actions.
Step-by-step explanation:
Without specific context about Article 11, it is not clear what Article 11 pertains to or what actions by Paul may be in violation of it.
To determine if Paul is in violation of Article 11, we would need to have the full text and context of Article 11, along with details of Paul's actions. Without this information, we cannot accurately assess whether Paul is in breach of Article 11's provisions.
The provided references to various sections of what appears to be Constitutional or legal provisions (No. 12 Constitutional Revision, Article II, Section 8, Article V, Section 13, Article XII, New Section Lobbying and Abuse of Office by Public Officers, etc.) suggest that the question is related to legal interpretations and possibly constitutional law.
However, without additional information, an accurate determination cannot be made.
In legal cases, facts and context are vital for a proper analysis. To proceed with an accurate judgment on whether Paul is in violation of Article 11, a full understanding of the relevant articles and Paul's actions are necessary.