113k views
3 votes
What are the problems associated with attempting to assign ancestries based on physical traits like skin color or other characteristics?

User Calandoa
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Assigning ancestries based on physical traits is inaccurate because these traits do not reliably indicate genetic background, and such racial classifications have no scientific basis. Focusing on race can lead to social issues such as racism and discrimination and has caused problems in medical diagnoses due to genetic variation within racial groups being greater than between them.

Step-by-step explanation:

There are significant problems with attempting to assign ancestries based on physical traits such as skin color, largely because these characteristics do not reliably indicate a person's genetic background or ancestry. Anthropologists, biologists, and geneticists have shown that the concept of race is not scientifically valid. For instance, of the 45,000 genetic markers in humans, only about 15 account for skin pigmentation. Thus, using physical traits like skin color, hair texture, and eye shape for racial classification is problematic.

This leads to the first major issue: the social construction of race. Different societies may choose to categorize by various traits, and if these constructions change, so too would the definitions of these races. Additionally, using race in this way risks associating unrelated traits with one's abilities or behaviors, which can lead to racism and discrimination.

Another problem is the biological perspective, where there is often more genetic variation within so-called racial groups than between them. Biological anthropologists have consistently demonstrated there are no discrete biologically-based racial categories, as human traits all vary along continuums and are mixed among individuals. Moreover, the focus on race in areas like medicine has caused issues with misdiagnoses and under-diagnoses of diseases, demonstrating the limitation of race as a factor in genetic research.

User Robertdj
by
7.5k points