84.7k views
1 vote
Literacy test results have been published in the local newspapers. They indictae that students in low-class neighborhoods of Toronto, who are of on particular cultural group, fare much poorly than students in upper-class area of the city. This leads many to believe that these students are not as smart as a result of the cultural group to which they belong

a) Nature
b) Nurture

User Jan Soltis
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

The question probes the influence of socioeconomic factors on literacy rates as reported in newspapers, pointing out that disparities in literacy test results across social classes in Toronto are more related to 'nurture' than 'nature.'

Step-by-step explanation:

The literacy test results published in local newspapers that indicate a disparity between students from low-class neighborhoods and those from upper-class areas in Toronto touch upon the complex interaction between 'nature' and 'nurture' in the realm of educational attainment and intelligence assessment. This difference in literacy rates is not indicative of innate intelligence but rather highlights the profound impact that socioeconomic status, cultural capital, and access to resources can have on a student's academic performance. The challenges faced by students in lower socioeconomic backgrounds include poorer study environments, lack of support, and additional responsibilities that can impede academic success. These external factors, rather than a student's cultural group, play a significant role in the variations seen in literacy tests.

Moreover, educational resources such as quality teaching and funding are not distributed equally, contributing to a gap in educational achievement. Conflict theorists argue that IQ tests and standardized tests like the SAT may be culturally biased, favoring the knowledge and experiences of more affluent students. These insights underscore the importance of considering the social and environmental contexts in which students learn, rather than attributing success or failure solely to innate 'smartness'.

User Samvermette
by
8.1k points