197k views
3 votes
One other-worldly approach to the metaphysical status of morality is the divine command theory. The idea that morality is related to God's will.

A. True
B. False

User Nukl
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The idea that morality is related to God's will according to the Divine Command Theory is true. This theory equates God's commands with what is morally good, irrespective of the nature of the action, leading to criticism and rejection by major organized religions.

Step-by-step explanation:

The statement that morality is related to God's will as per the Divine Command Theory is True. Divine Command Theory posits that what is morally good is determined by what God commands, and there is no inherent good or bad outside of these divine commands. Under this theory, an act, no matter its nature, is considered good if God commands it, and bad if God forbids it. This creates a significant issue: if morality is solely based on divine edicts, actions that are commonly seen as abhorrent can be deemed good just because God commands them, such as cases highlighted by the Euthyphro problem. This has led to significant criticism of the theory and is a reason why it isn't adopted by major organized religions as the basis for their moral frameworks.

Moreover, Divine Command Theory does not rest on any scripture but solely on what is relayed as God's command, which can change and even contradict previous commands. This theory is less about following established religious texts, like the Ten Commandments, and more about the dynamic and potentially changing will of the deity. Because of the inherent problems with this approach, such as arbitrariness and lack of independent moral reasoning, many argue against its validity and applicability to complex moral situations.

User Jonathan Winks
by
7.6k points