Whether Congress should more accurately reflect the gender/ethnic breakdown of the US is a complex issue with strong arguments on both sides.
Arguments for:
Fairness and representation: A Congress that more closely mirrors the population's demographics would be more likely to represent the diverse needs and concerns of all citizens. This could lead to more equitable and inclusive policies.
Breaking down barriers: Increased representation of different genders and ethnicities could inspire and encourage others from those groups to seek public office, breaking down existing barriers to political participation.
Arguments against:
Focus on qualifications: Qualifications, experience, and policy competence should be the primary factors in electing representatives, regardless of their gender or ethnicity.
Tyranny of the majority: Some argue that focusing on demographics could lead to policies favoring certain groups over others, potentially undermining individual rights and freedoms.
Logistical challenges: Achieving perfect proportional representation can be difficult due to factors like gerrymandering and the Electoral College.