70.4k views
2 votes
Why does the speaker accuse the poem "Beware: Do not read this poem" of having no manners?

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The speaker accuses the poem of having no manners due to its unconventional approach, reflecting ongoing debates about the nature and value of poetry across history. The accusation suggests a breach in the expected decorum of literary creation.

Step-by-step explanation:

The speaker in "Beware: Do not read this poem" accuses the poem of having no manners because it flaunts conventional expectations and acts outside of societal norms, just as someone with poor manners might. This artistic expression can sometimes come across as brash or disrespectful to the formality of traditional poetry, which is why the speaker might make such an accusation. The poem's subject and presentation challenge the reader to reconsider their understanding of what constitutes poetic form and content, which can be both intriguing and unsettling.

In the context of the lines shared and the broader discussion of poetry and its place in society, this notion of a poem being without manners ties into historical arguments about the value of literature. Sir Philip Sydney's defense of poetry against its critics in the late 1500s is a callback to the perennial debate about the purpose and propriety of poetic works. This underscores the timeless nature of such confrontations between creative freedom and cultural expectations.

The overarching theme of this analysis is that poetry is a reflection of the poet's intent and societal norms, and the way it is received can change throughout history. This reception is contingent upon cultural norms, societal values, and the expectations of the readers, highlighting the subjective nature of artistic appreciation and the dynamic relationship between poetry and the audience.

User Sharren
by
7.6k points