23.2k views
4 votes
Cases that are more political in nature are NOT heard by the federal judiciary. How are they decided?

User AmeyaB
by
8.9k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

Cases with a political nature that involve a federal question or a federal party can be heard by the federal judiciary, while other political cases are often decided at the state level, influenced by the political culture and selection method for judges.

Step-by-step explanation:

Cases that are more political in nature may still be decided through the judicial process, particularly if they involve a federal question, which includes issues related to the Constitution, federal laws, or treaties, or when a federal party is involved. If such cases do not fall under the jurisdiction of the federal judiciary, they could be decided at the state level. State courts handle a wide variety of cases, including most criminal cases and civil matters. Moreover, the decisions in these state court systems can be influenced by the political culture and the selection method of judges, with elected judges potentially ruling differently than appointed ones. In some instances, cases can move through the dual court system and be heard in both state and federal courts, with the potential to make it to the U.S. Supreme Court if a substantial federal question is at stake.

User Josue
by
7.7k points

No related questions found