83.9k views
4 votes
Supreme Court decisions by the Roberts Court on issues like environmental protection and partial-birth abortions demonstrate that the Court __________ at that time.

a. leaned toward more conservative ideologies
b. believed in judicial activism
c. interpreted the Constitution strictly
d. supported the rights of the individual over the rights of the state
e. placed state's rights before that of the federal government

User Rkallensee
by
8.0k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

The Roberts Court's decisions on environmental protection and partial-birth abortions indicate a lean towards conservative ideologies, which can involve elements of both judicial activism and judicial restraint, depending on the specific case and context.

Step-by-step explanation:

During the era of the Roberts Court, decisions on issues such as environmental protection and partial-birth abortions indicated a leaning toward more conservative ideologies. The Court's rulings showcased a dynamic interplay between judicial activism and restraint. In cases involving societal changes and individual rights, the Court displayed elements of judicial activism by actively interpreting the Constitution. Conversely, instances of judicial restraint and strict constructionism were evident, particularly in decisions favoring states' rights over federal power.

For example, in striking down the Gun-Free School Zone Act, the Court interpreted the Constitution based on perceived original intentions of the framers, showcasing a commitment to limiting federal authority. This nuanced approach reflects the multifaceted nature of the Court's jurisprudence, demonstrating a blend of conservative principles, judicial activism, and deference to constitutional interpretation.

User Hendrick
by
8.0k points