84.6k views
4 votes
Which is standardly thought to be directly analogous to the trolley car problem?

A. The fat man variant

B. The surgeon variant

C. The loop variant

D. The switch variant

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The switch variant (D) is the option that is standardly thought to be directly analogous to the classic trolley car problem, which involves a similar ethical dilemma regarding the decision to pull a lever to save lives. The correct option is D. The switch variant

Step-by-step explanation:

The question you have asked is related to the ethical thought experiments known as the trolley problems, which are used to examine moral decision-making. Specifically, you are asking about a variation of the trolley problem that is directly analogous to the classic trolley car scenario, which is known as the bystander case.

The option that is standardly thought to be directly analogous to the classic trolley car problem is D. The switch variant. This variant involves a similar setup where a person can choose to pull a lever, thus changing the path of the trolley to move from a track that would kill five people to a track that would kill one person.

The fat man, surgeon, and loop variants also explore similar ethical terrain but present different scenarios and nuances to consider and are not as directly comparable to the classic case as the switch variant. The correct option is D. The switch variant

User Ecurbh
by
8.2k points