164k views
3 votes
How do the Jews respond to Pilates question "Shall I crucify your lord king?"

User Eliego
by
8.8k points

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

In response to Pilate's question about crucifying Jesus, the crowd in the Gospel narrative calls for crucifixion, reflecting the intricate religious and political dynamics of Judea under Roman rule. The crucifixion itself is understood as a Roman response to what was perceived as rebellion, with the Jewish leadership seeing Jesus as a disruptor to the status quo.

Step-by-step explanation:

In response to Pontius Pilate asking, "Shall I crucify your lord king?" the Gospels recount that the crowd, influenced by the chief priests, called for Jesus to be crucified. The context of this historical moment reflects the complex social and religious tensions of the time.

According to the biblical narrative, though many Jews saw Jesus as a teacher and perhaps even a prophet, the leadership, particularly the Sadducees and Pharisees, viewed him as a threat to the established order and potentially to the uneasy peace with the Roman occupiers. This opposition, coupled with Roman procedures for dealing with perceived rebels, led to Jesus' crucifixion, a punishment typically reserved for political insurrectionists and criminals against the state.

The Roman territory of Judea was a hotspot of tension, especially between the Jews, who were uncompromising monotheists, and the Romans, who demanded emperor worship.

The Jewish population largely detested the heavy Roman taxation and longed for a messianic figure to free them from Roman rule. However, the expectation of the Messiah differed among the Jewish people; some hoped for a political savior while others, like the early Christians, believed in spiritual salvation through Jesus' sacrifice.

User Auras
by
8.1k points
5 votes
"We have no king but Caesar." This response indicates a rejection of Jesus as their king and an acknowledgment of Caesar as the ruling authority.
User Liviu Trifoi
by
7.3k points