168k views
5 votes
Serological testing on a potential donor reveals a positive HIV antibody screening test. The screening test is positive on repeat testing, but the confirmatory test result is negative. What happens to the tissue.

a. May not be used; discrepant results obtained
b. May be used; HIV antibody test is not a required test
c. May be used; confirmatory test is negative
d. May not be used; results of confirmatory test cannot override a screening test

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

In the instance of discrepant serological test results for HIV — a positive antibody screening followed by a negative confirmatory test — the potential donor's tissue may not be used. This approach ensures safety by requiring positive screenings to be effectively ruled out by confirmatory tests before tissue is approved for use.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the case of a potential donor with a positive initial HIV antibody screening that is not confirmed by a subsequent confirmatory test, the tissue may not be used due to the discrepant results obtained. Such scenarios highlight the importance of confirmatory testing in serological diagnosis to rule out false positives that may arise from cross-reactivity or other factors.

Serological testing often starts with an ELISA (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) which is highly sensitive but may yield false positives. False positives can arise because antibodies developed in response to one pathogen may cross-react with antigens from another pathogen, which in this case, is the HIV viral peptides used in the test.

In this context, the appropriate action is to adhere to the guideline that discrepant results invalidate the use of the tissue, owing to the potential risk of transferring an infection.

Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.