157k views
5 votes
Is ambiguity or vagueness the main problem with this claim?

"Now, how would you like your hair cut, Madam?"
claim: "Oh, just make it a little shorter."

User Ates Goral
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The claim 'Oh, just make it a little shorter' is ambiguous, lacking in detail which can lead to misinterpretation and unintended haircut results, as exemplified by characters in the provided excerpts.

Step-by-step explanation:

The claim, "Oh, just make it a little shorter," posed by a customer to a barber, illustrates a case of ambiguity. Ambiguity arises when a statement or instruction is open to multiple interpretations, lacking clear, definitive direction.

In the context of haircut instructions, such a claim lacks specificity, which can lead to an outcome that does not align with the customer's expectations, as seen in the provided excerpts where a character experiences regret after a dramatic hair alteration. The haircuts described in these passages are significant changes that go beyond making the hair 'a little shorter,' suggesting that the claim's brevity and non-specificity set the stage for miscommunication.

There are several vivid examples provided that show the consequences of such ambiguity. For instance, a character ends up with 'lank lifeless blocks' instead of curls, causing her distress. Another character decides to bob her hair, foregoing further discussion, initiating a significant transformation without the barber having a clear understanding of her desire. These scenarios underpin the importance of precise communication in avoiding undesired outcomes.

User Octavian Niculescu
by
8.5k points