Question

Read this excerpt from P.J.A. Bert's "The Bell Rock."

Whilst the true historical background to these events may never be fully untangled, it is clear that by the early 1800s the Rock was recognised as a major hazard, a fact reinforced as a consequence of a three-day storm in 1799 in which some 70 ships were wrecked around the Scottish coast, including a number on the Rock, and the loss of HMS York on Inchcape in 1804.

How does the author's use of the phrase may never be fully untangled affect the tone of the excerpt?

It supports a persuasive tone intended to make the author's arguments convincing.


It supports a conversational tone that prompts the reader to trust the author.


It supports a lighthearted tone intended to keep the reader interested.


It supports an objective tone by acknowledging that not all the facts are known.

Answer 1

The phrase 'may never be fully untangled' supports an objective tone by acknowledging the limitations in understanding historical events fully.

Step-by-step explanation:

The author's use of the phrase "may never be fully untangled" affects the tone of the excerpt by suggesting an acknowledgment of the complexity and uncertainty surrounding historical events. This expression supports an objective tone because it indicates that the truth behind historical facts can be elusive and acknowledges the limitations in fully understanding what occurred. Whilst the piece mentions a significant historical event, the language employed does not aim to persuade, conversely it invites the reader to consider the inherent difficulties in deciphering the complete history of events like those involving the Bell Rock and the wrecks that occurred there. The author conveys a respectful treatment of history, signaling a clear awareness that knowledge has its bounds.

The author's use of the phrase 'may never be fully untangled' supports an objective tone by acknowledging that not all the facts are known. The phrase suggests that there is still uncertainty surrounding the true historical background of the events described. This objective tone helps to convey the idea that further investigation or research is needed to fully understand the history of the Rock and the events mentioned.