Question

5. Look at King Claudius' passage that begins, "'Tis sweet and commendable in your nature, Hamlet." List four of the reasons that Claudius says Hamlet ought to stop grieving. What do you think of Claudius' arguments?

Answer 1

King Claudius presents four reasons why Hamlet should stop grieving, including the unproductiveness of excessive grief and the need to fulfill his responsibilities as the Prince of Denmark.

Step-by-step explanation:

In the passage, King Claudius presents four reasons why Hamlet ought to stop grieving:

1. He suggests that Hamlet's excessive grief is not only unproductive but also goes against his natural disposition. Claudius argues that it is commendable for Hamlet to mourn his father's death, but he should not let it consume him.
2. Claudius believes that Hamlet's grief is causing him to neglect his responsibilities as the Prince of Denmark. He wants Hamlet to focus on his duties to the kingdom rather than indulging in his sorrow.
3. Another reason Claudius gives is that Hamlet's extended mourning may be misconstrued as a sign of weakness. He points out that a leader should demonstrate strength and resilience, especially during challenging times.
4. Lastly, Claudius suggests that Hamlet's grief is disproportionate considering that death is an inevitable part of life. He argues that everyone experiences loss, and it is important for Hamlet to recognize this and move forward.

Regarding Claudius' arguments, it is important to note that his intentions may not be entirely genuine. As the new king and the murderer of Hamlet's father, Claudius has a self-serving interest in controlling Hamlet's emotions. Despite this, Claudius does make some valid points about the need for moderation in grieving and the importance of fulfilling one's responsibilities.