Final answer:
Sebastian Junger used the real crew of the Andrea Gail as the basis for the tragedy in 'The Perfect Storm.' Mary Rowlandson's faith sustained her during her captivity, and her narrative is compelling due to the dramatic and cultural depth it provides. Harding Davis challenges her upper-class readership to acknowledge and reconcile with the hardships of industrial workers.
Step-by-step explanation:
The group that provides Sebastian Junger with the basis upon which he creates the tragedy that strikes the Andrea Gail is the actual crew members of the fishing vessel Andrea Gail. In his book The Perfect Storm, Junger recounts the true story of this commercial fishing boat that was lost at sea during the 1991 Halloween nor'easter.
The tragedy was a result of multiple meteorological factors that combined to form what was termed "the perfect storm."
Regarding the narrative of Mary Rowlandson, Rowlandson's faith sustains her during her ordeal of being held captive by Native Americans. She characterizes her captors in complex ways, at times barbaric and at other times kind, reflective of her shifting perceptions over time.
The narrative's compelling nature is largely derived from Rowlandson's introspective journey, the vivid and dramatic encounters she describes, and the cultural interactions she experiences.
In contrast, Harding Davis challenges readers of her story to confront the realities of industrial workers' lives. The story holds particular resonance as its initial readership, the subscribers of the Atlantic magazine, were from the upper-class society, vastly different from the iron workers depicted.
The novella directly addresses the discrepancy between readers' lives and the hardships described, urging them to reconcile their comfortable existence with the harsh realities faced by others.