202k views
3 votes
Like many states, Nevada elects its judges (whereas federal court judges are appointed). What are the advantages and disadvantages of electing judges? Consider the federal judicial process whereby federal judges are nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate and serve for life. Would you like to see Nevada use appointments instead of elections to select its judges? In 2010 Nevada voters failed to support a ballot initiative that would have amended the Constitution to create a process

User Zs Felber
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Electing judges in Nevada and the federal judicial process of appointing judges have both advantages and disadvantages. The advantage of electing judges is democratic representation and accountability, while the disadvantage is potential bias. The federal process allows for oversight and scrutiny of candidates, but lifetime appointments provide independence.

Step-by-step explanation:

Electing judges in Nevada and the federal judicial process of appointing judges have both advantages and disadvantages. One advantage of electing judges is that it allows for a more democratic process, with voters having a say in who is appointed as a judge. This can increase accountability and representativeness. On the other hand, one disadvantage is that the election process can be influenced by political factors, leading to potential bias in the selection of judges. In contrast, the federal process of nominating and confirming judges allows for more oversight and scrutiny of candidates, potentially resulting in more qualified judges. Additionally, lifetime appointments for federal judges provide independence from political pressures.

Whether Nevada should use appointments instead of elections to select its judges is a matter of opinion. Some may argue that appointments would ensure a more merit-based selection process, while others may argue that elections provide for greater democratic control. Ultimately, it depends on the values and priorities of the citizens of Nevada.

User Lncr
by
8.2k points