159k views
3 votes
Which of these carbocations is most stable?

a. the sec -butyl cation
b. the isobutyl cation
c. the n -butyl cation

User Codious
by
7.4k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

The sec-butyl cation is the most stable carbocation among the given options due to it being a secondary carbocation with greater stabilizing effects such as hyperconjugation and inductive effects compared to the isobutyl and n-butyl cations.

Step-by-step explanation:

The stability of carbocations increases in the order of primary (RCH₂) < secondary (R₂CH) < tertiary (R₃C). Therefore, between the sec-butyl cation, the isobutyl cation, and the n-butyl cation, the most stable is the sec-butyl cation.

This is because the sec-butyl cation is a secondary carbocation, whereas the n-butyl cation is a primary carbocation, and stability is less for primary carbocations. The isobutyl group is less stable due to less hyperconjugation when compared to the sec-butyl cation.

The mentioned correct option in the final answer is the sec-butyl cation, which is the most stable out of the options given.

User Ingulit
by
7.5k points