176k views
4 votes
jane gave a persuasive speech on adopting pets rather than buying pets. jane stated that adopting pets makes one a caring, considerate person who controls the pet population but buying pets makes one selfish and uncaring towards animals and will cause the pet population to explode. jane has committed what type of logical fallacy?

1 Answer

6 votes

Final answer:

Jane has committed a False Dichotomy by presenting adopting pets as morally superior and buying pets as selfish, without considering other alternatives or reasons.

Step-by-step explanation:

Jane's persuasive speech on adopting pets rather than buying pets, where she states that adopting pets makes one a caring, considerate person, but buying pets makes one selfish and careless towards animals, has committed a logical fallacy known as a False Dichotomy. This fallacy occurs when only two extremes are presented as the only possible options when, in reality, there are other viable alternatives. Jane's argument presents a distorted viewpoint by oversimplifying the complexities of pet adoption and purchase, implying that one option is morally superior while the other is unethical, which fails to consider the nuanced reasons behind an individual's choice.

User Chintan Soni
by
8.6k points