Final answer:
The sea otter is the keystone species in the Aleutian Islands ecosystem, as their presence controls sea urchin populations and supports kelp forest ecosystems.
Step-by-step explanation:
In the described scenario from the Aleutian Islands of Alaska, the correct identification of the keystone species is the sea otter. As the otters were hunted to near extinction, their absence allowed the population of sea urchins, which are herbivorous grazers, to increase substantially. The unchecked growth of the urchin population led to the overconsumption of kelp, resulting in a significant decline in kelp forests. This cascade effect underscores the critical role sea otters play in maintaining the balance of the ecosystem by preying on urchins, thus controlling their numbers and subsequently supporting kelp forest ecosystems.