94.2k views
0 votes
Why did Franklin Roosevelt propose expanding the number of Supreme Court justices?

-President Roosevelt was concerned that several justices were too old to serve on the Supreme Court but was concerned about his image if he simply fired justices due to their age.
-President Roosevelt recognized that the workload of the Supreme Court was becoming unbearable and wanted to spread the work among additional justices.
-President Roosevelt wanted to ensure that there would be an odd number of Supreme Court justices so that fewer decisions would end in a tie vote.
-President Roosevelt was unhappy with recent Supreme Court decisions and wanted to change the composition of the Court so that it would be more sympathetic to his policies.

User Avner Levy
by
8.2k points

1 Answer

1 vote

Final answer:

President Franklin Roosevelt's attempt to expand the Supreme Court in 1937 was a strategic move to appoint justices who would support his New Deal policies, despite presenting the proposal as an effort to ease the workload for older justices. The correct answer is option 4.

Step-by-step explanation:

President Franklin Roosevelt proposed expanding the number of Supreme Court justices through his Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937, commonly referred to as the "court-packing scheme". Roosevelt's official justification was to alleviate the workload of the Court and to provide assistance to older justices. However, the true motive was rooted in his frustration with the Supreme Court for striking down key components of his New Deal legislation, which were aimed at addressing the problems of the Great Depression. The plan would grant him the power to appoint additional justices sympathetic to his policies, specifically by adding one justice for each sitting justice over the age of seventy. This would have potentially expanded the Court from nine to as many as fifteen justices. Despite the contentious nature of this proposal, Roosevelt never implemented the plan, although the political pressure may have influenced subsequent Court decisions more favorable to the New Deal.

User Nitin Labhishetty
by
7.8k points