169k views
2 votes
A scientist has claimed to have discovered a new particle that has a charge of of the elementary charge. Which of the following is a correct statement about this claim? Select two answers.

A. The accepted model for representing particles requires that this particle always be paired with a second particle that has a charge of "where n is an odd integer, so that the composite particle has a charge that is an integer multiple of the elementary charge.
B. An error was made, since it is impossible for anything to have a charge less than the elementary charge.
C. The scientist must create a model for representing particles that allows for particles with charge of of the elementary charge in order for the claim to be valid.
D. Other scientists should perform more experiments before the claim is accepted or rejected.

User MJay
by
8.4k points

1 Answer

5 votes

The correct statements about the scientist's claim are:

C. The scientist must create a model for representing particles that allows for particles with a charge of ½ of the elementary charge in order for the claim to be valid.

D. Other scientists should perform more experiments before the claim is accepted or rejected.

A. The accepted model for representing particles requires that this particle always be paired with a second particle that has a charge of "where n is an odd integer, so that the composite particle has a charge that is an integer multiple of the elementary charge. This statement is incorrect because the claim is about a particle with a charge of ½ of the elementary charge, not an odd multiple of the elementary charge.

B. An error was made, since it is impossible for anything to have a charge less than the elementary charge. This statement is also incorrect because there are particles known as quarks that have fractional charges, such as ⅓ or ⅔ of the elementary charge.

C. The scientist must create a model for representing particles that allows for particles with a charge of ½ of the elementary charge in order for the claim to be valid. This statement is correct because the claim challenges the current understanding of particle physics, which assumes charges to be integer multiples of the elementary charge. The scientist would need to propose a new model or theory that accommodates particles with a charge of ½ of the elementary charge.

D. Other scientists should perform more experiments before the claim is accepted or rejected. This statement is correct because scientific claims need to be rigorously tested and verified by independent researchers. Additional experiments and analysis are necessary to confirm or refute the claim made by the scientist.

Therefore, the correct statements about the scientist's claim are:

C. The scientist must create a model for representing particles that allows for particles with a charge of ½ of the elementary charge in order for the claim to be valid.

D. Other scientists should perform more experiments before the claim is accepted or rejected.

User Damian Peralta
by
7.9k points

No related questions found