Final answer:
The isolation, lawlessness, and violence of frontier life would have been the most bothersome aspects to me. A transition from a nomadic to a settled lifestyle would greatly impact the social structure and personal security, with both positive and negative potential outcomes. The end of the frontier marked a significant shift in American identity.
Step-by-step explanation:
The aspect of frontier life that would have likely bothered me the most is the isolation and lawlessness that were common during this time. This aspect of life is vividly depicted in accounts of settlers and outcasts who faced immense hardships in the Wild West. The challenges of a transition from a nomadic to a settled way of life would have altered the social fabric, likely resulting in a sense of loneliness and vulnerability. My standard of living could be better in terms of acquiring land and the potential for self-sufficiency, but worse in terms of security, law and order, and access to community and medical care.
Furthermore, the dark narrative provided by Frederick Jackson Turner, which presents a view of the frontier as a place tearing at the very fabric of democracy, the end of the frontier equated to not just an end of a geographical boundary but also the cessation of a certain kind of American ingenuity and spirit. The disappearance of the frontier signified not just a geographical change, but an impending shift in the American identity and its socio-political ramifications.
Last but not least, the cruelty and omnipresent risk of violence on the frontier life, as depicted in narratives of the time, paint a grim picture. With issues like slavery, blood feuds, and the harsh confrontation with native wilderness, the frontier was marked by an almost palpable tension and the constant presence of death. The frontier's uncomfortable blend of freedom and constant danger is a dual-edged sword that embodies a pioneering spirit while also revealing the bloody past of American expansion.