169k views
0 votes
In order for government to discriminate against people based on their race, the government is required to provide

a) compelling reason
b) reasonable justification
c) logical explanation
d) all of the above

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The correct option is b. In order for the government to discriminate against people based on their race, the government is required to provide a reasonable justification.

Step-by-step explanation:

The answer to this question lies in the purpose of the discriminatory practice. In most cases when the courts are deciding whether discrimination is unlawful, the government has to demonstrate only that it has a good reason to do so. Unless the person or group challenging the law can prove otherwise, the courts will generally decide the discriminatory practice is allowed. In these cases, the courts are applying the rational basis test. That is, as long as there's a reason for treating some people differently that is 'rationally related to a legitimate government interest,' the discriminatory act or law or policy is acceptable.

For example, since letting blind people operate cars would be dangerous to others on the road, the law forbidding them to drive is reasonably justified on the grounds of safety and is therefore allowed even though it discriminates against the blind. Similarly, when universities and colleges refuse to admit students who fail to meet a certain test score or GPA, they can discriminate against students with weaker grades and test scores because these students most likely do not yet possess the knowledge or skills needed to do well in their classes and graduate from the institution. The universities and colleges have a legitimate reason for denying these students entrance.

User Giuseppe Schembri
by
8.3k points