128k views
2 votes
What is a major criticism of the Rorschach test?

a) It should not be used with individuals who have psychological disorders such as depression.
b) It does not provide the person giving the test as much flexibility as a personality inventory.
c) The scoring systems are neither reliable nor valid.
d) Because it is an objective test, the test taker's responses are extremely limited.

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The significant critique of the Rorschach test is its unreliable and invalid scoring systems, which may lead to inconsistent and subjective interpretations of psychological states.

Step-by-step explanation:

The major criticism of the Rorschach test is that its scoring systems are neither reliable nor valid (option c).

The Rorschach Inkblot Test is a psychological assessment tool used to analyze a person's underlying emotional states and personality traits. Developed by Hermann Rorschach, it employs a series of inkblots presented to individuals, who are then asked to describe what they see. The underlying principle is that by interpreting these ambiguous images, it's possible to reveal the person's unconscious desires, fears, and struggles. Despite its historical significance and standardized Exner scoring system, the test has faced substantial criticism for its lack of reliability and validity. Reliability refers to the consistency of the results obtained, while validity examines whether the test truly measures what it claims to measure. Critics argue that the highly subjective nature of the response interpretation can lead to inconsistent and invalid assessments, limiting its usefulness in clinical and legal settings. Due to these issues, the Rorschach has often been compared unfavorably to objective assessments like self-report inventories, which use structured formats to evaluate personality.

User Michael Doye
by
8.3k points