Question

You and your peer, Juan, have been assigned to work together on a nursing presentation. You both have different approaches on how to do the presentation; however, each approach would be very effective. After reviewing the assignment guidelines you both realize the assignment is due a week earlier than initially expected. What would be the best Thomas-Kilman conflict management approach to this situation?

a) One person will have to accommodate and the other person will have to compete in order to meet the presentation due date. Then work together on the presentation
b) One personal will have to avoid and the other person will have to compete in order to meet presentation due date. They will then work together on the presentation
c) Both parties can compete as each one had an effective presentation approach and then work to put the presentation together
d) Both group members have a very effective approach, therefore it is best to compromise and come up with a solution that is middle ground

Answer 1

The best Thomas-Kilman conflict management approach for you and Juan, who must collaborate on an early-due nursing presentation with different but effective ideas, is to compromise and combine both approaches to build a collaborative and comprehensive presentation.

Step-by-step explanation:

When you and your peer, Juan, have been assigned to work together on a nursing presentation with different effective approaches and a pressing deadline, the best conflict resolution method is to apply the compromise style prescribed by the Thomas-Kilman conflict management model. This approach involves merging ideas from both parties to create a cohesive and effective presentation. Compromise is especially advantageous because it incorporates the strengths of both approaches and deepens collaboration, which is critical in conflict management and the success of any team-oriented project. This reflects the need to align team members' ideas for sustainable collaboration, as well as the importance of good communication and negotiation skills to prevent and manage disputes effectively.

Compromise enables both you and Juan to work together constructively and, importantly, to meet the earlier than expected deadline without resorting to one-sided solutions or unnecessary competition, both of which could be detrimental under time constraints. This middle-ground solution is generally the most equitable and maintains a high level of group functioning, which is essential for a successful nursing presentation.