194k views
5 votes
If you amend any motion, is it debatable?

User Metro
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

In the U.S. Senate, amendments to motions can lead to unlimited debate which continues until no senators wish to speak or a motion to table is voted on. These amendments do not have to be germane, allowing for a broad discussion on the motion.

Step-by-step explanation:

Within the legislative process, specifically concerning the United States Senate, amendments to motions can indeed provoke debate. It is part of the Senate action where unlimited debate is allowed.

The unique attribute of these amendments in the Senate is that they do not have to be germane, meaning they don't necessarily have to be closely related to the subject matter of the motion being amended. This can potentially open the floor to a wide array of discussions and deliberations. The trigger to end the debate is practical rather than procedural; it concludes when there are no senators who seek to be recognized for further discussion.

Moreover, it is important to understand that debate can only conclude when a motion to table is offered and voted on, unless earlier unanimous consent for time limitation is achieved. This structure embodies the Senate's principles of extended debate and thorough discussion on legislative matters.

User Srf
by
7.7k points