36.9k views
2 votes
How would explain the following quote?

" It is not necessary that the [Constitution] should be perfect; it is sufficient that [the Articles of Confederation are] more imperfect." James Madison

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

James Madison posited that perfection was not necessary for the Constitution, but rather it being an improvement over the deeply flawed Articles of Confederation was sufficient. The Constitution was crafted to create a stronger central government and had provisions for amendment, enabling it to adapt over time.

Step-by-step explanation:

The quote by James Madison, "It is not necessary that the [Constitution] should be perfect; it is sufficient that [the Articles of Confederation are] more imperfect," reflects the pragmatic approach the framers of the Constitution took when they convened to create a new form of government. They understood that while the newly proposed Constitution might not be flawless, it was a significant improvement over the Articles of Confederation. The Articles were seen as inadequate because they did not provide a strong central government, lacked the ability to enforce federal laws or collect taxes effectively, and required unanimity for amendments, which made changes nearly impossible.

Madison was instrumental in shaping the Constitution, advocating for a system that had a bi-cameral legislature, separate judicial and executive branches, and stronger federal powers. He, alongside other Federalists, believed that a stronger government would protect the nation and ensure the general welfare of its citizens, in contrast to the impotence of the Confederation Congress. Ultimately, the framers of the Constitution included a means to amend the document, allowing it to evolve and address the needs and challenges of a changing nation.

User Mauren
by
7.9k points