Question

In Lord of the Flies, in what ways is Ralph an effective or ineffective leader? In what ways is Jack effective or ineffective as a leader? Which of the two leaders is better for the boys and why? Using MLA format, write a TBEAR body paragraph explaining the prompt. Your paragraph should include a transition with a topic, background information, two pieces of evidence with at least three sentences of analysis for each piece of evidence, and a summary statement (restate). You must cite all of your evidence and include a Works Cited page below your discussion post. Once you are finished, go through and help edit at least two of your peers' replies.

Answer 1

In Lord of the Flies, Ralph is an effective leader because he establishes rules and order, while Jack is an ineffective leader because he becomes consumed by power and encourages violence. Ralph is better for the boys because his leadership style promotes cooperation and the preservation of civilization.

Step-by-step explanation:

Topic: In what ways is Ralph an effective or ineffective leader? In what ways is Jack effective or ineffective as a leader? Which of the two leaders is better for the boys and why?

Background information: In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, Ralph and Jack emerge as leaders among a group of boys stranded on a deserted island. Ralph is initially chosen as the leader due to his charisma and ability to bring the boys together. Jack, on the other hand, represents the dark side of human nature and quickly becomes a rival leader.

1. Evidence 1: Ralph is an effective leader because he establishes rules and order on the island. For example, he creates the conch shell as a symbol of authority and uses it to call meetings and maintain order.
2. Analysis: By establishing rules and order, Ralph ensures that the boys have a sense of structure and can work together towards a common goal. This shows his ability to take charge and make decisions that benefit the group as a whole.
3. Evidence 2: Jack is an ineffective leader because he becomes consumed by the desire for power and control. He forms his own faction and encourages violence and savagery among the boys.
4. Analysis: Jack's obsession with power leads to the disintegration of the group and the loss of civilization. His lack of empathy and disregard for the well-being of others make him a dangerous and ineffective leader.

Summary statement: In conclusion, Ralph proves to be a more effective leader than Jack in Lord of the Flies. His ability to establish rules and maintain order shows his leadership qualities, while Jack's obsession with power leads to chaos and destruction. Ralph's leadership style is better for the boys because it promotes cooperation and the preservation of civilization.