47.4k views
5 votes
What is the federal policy regarding polygraph testing of federal employees?

User Stackr
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The federal policy on polygraph testing for federal employees is subject to specific protocols, often used for security clearances or sensitive positions. Its accuracy is debated, and legal protections ensure employees are not discriminated against or compelled to self-incriminate during the process.

Step-by-step explanation:

The federal policy regarding polygraph testing of federal employees can be complex and variable depending on the agency and the position. Generally, the use of polygraphs for federal employees aligns with the Employee Polygraph Protection Act of 1988, which restricts the use of lie detector tests in employment and is mostly applicable to private sector employees, but with exemptions for governmental agencies. However, its accuracy has been questioned, as suggested by Saxe & Ben-Shakhar (1999) who note that there is no evidence that lying is associated with a specific pattern of physiological arousal which a polygraph would detect.

Federal agencies that conduct polygraph tests must follow specific protocols and cannot use them indiscriminately, often reserving them for security clearance processes or positions involving national security. Moreover, guidelines against discrimination, such as those highlighted during the Lavender Scare, have evolved to protect employees from unfair employment practices based on personal information that may be exposed during polygraph testing.

In relation to the Fifth Amendment and self-incrimination, the use of polygraph tests by law enforcement must align with legal protections afforded to individuals, ensuring that their rights to counsel and protection against self-incrimination are not violated during interrogations.

User JasonE
by
8.5k points