134k views
4 votes
Whenever the jury finds Socrates guilty, they offer him the opportunity to advocate for a particular sentence. Why do you think he responds in the way that he does? Is Socrates simply goading the court to kill him, or does he have some other goal in mind?

a) Socrates wants to provoke the court to punish him severely
b) He wishes to assert his innocence more strongly
c) Socrates aims to challenge the court's sense of justice and morality
d) He seeks to escape the court's judgment

User CasualT
by
7.2k points

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Socrates responds to the sentencing opportunity by challenging the jury's sense of justice and highlighting his commitment to philosophical inquiry and truth. He provocatively suggests a reward instead of a punishment, which offends the jurors, and asserts the importance of virtue over self-preservation, resulting in his death sentence.

Step-by-step explanation:

When the jury finds Socrates guilty and allows him to advocate for a sentence, his response is multi-layered. Socrates is steadfast in asserting his innocence and commitment to a life of philosophical inquiry, as well as seeking to highlight the shortcomings of the Athenian justice system and the implications of their choices for their morality and the city's reputation. He provocatively suggests that rather than a punishment, he deserves free room and board for his services to the state, challenging the jurors to examine their own values and the justice of their decision-making.

Throughout the trial and subsequent conviction, Socrates's priority is to remain faithful to his oath and principles, even if that means facing a death sentence. His actions and words aim to scrutinize and elevate the societal understanding of justice and morality, demonstrating a dedication to truth and virtue over self-preservation, which ultimately leads to a sentence of death.

In his engagement with the charges, both prior to and after the verdict, Socrates stands as a defender of a philosophical life, questioning established beliefs and norms, and prioritizing the pursuit of wisdom over succumbing to societal pressures or fear of death. His responses and defenses are immortalized in Plato's dialogues, serving as a powerful legacy of the philosopher's life and death.

User Kurt Acosta
by
7.6k points