Question

Thea, the mayor of Highland takes a classical approach to the problem of crime. However, after a media appearance, she is criticized by Luke, a political opponent. Which of the following is most likely to be the basis for Luke's criticism?

A) Thea's emphasis on punishment over rehabilitation
B) Thea's reliance on social programs to address crime
C) Thea's focus on individual responsibility for criminal behavior
D) Thea's rejection of deterrence as a crime control strategy

Answer 1

The basis for Luke's criticism of Mayor Thea's classical approach to crime would likely be her emphasis on punishment over rehabilitation, considering that the classical approach often prioritizes punitive measures and deterrence while not focusing on socio-economic factors or transformative efforts.

Step-by-step explanation:

If Thea, the mayor of Highland, takes a classical approach to the problem of crime, she is likely emphasizing punishment and deterrence as main strategies for addressing crime. Given that this approach focuses on the idea that jail time is both punitive and serves as a deterrent, Luke's criticism would most likely be based on Thea's emphasis on punishment over rehabilitation.

The classical approach does not prioritize rehabilitative efforts, which are designed to transform an offender into a productive member of society, nor does it typically focus on investing in social programs or addressing individual responsibility in a non-punitive way.

Therefore, the critique from Luke, the political opponent, would likely focus on the lack of rehabilitation initiatives and excessive reliance on incarceration as a primary means of controlling crime, which could potentially ignore underlying causes like poverty, limited education, and unemployment that increase the opportunity costs of crime for individuals.