To evaluate Jamal and George's solutions for the quadratic equation
, let's examine their work.
Jamal's Solution:
![\[ x^2 + 4x - 5 - 7 = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/vxlbkbi9wg4m5pthz2bzqw8y2bo78kwz6i.png)
![\[ x^2 + 4x - 12 = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/cs2r315z7nm6p5jng4o5x3e6zymi9heu4o.png)
![\[ (x - 2)(x + 6) = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/3budlqnqf0w3rxcgdw6bb7s5mw9up5v9pu.png)
![\[ x = 2, -6 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/d5gd3el1xhteu9ss4lq65qz0q4qnux061s.png)
George's Solution:
![\[ x^2 + 4x - 5 - 7 = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/vxlbkbi9wg4m5pthz2bzqw8y2bo78kwz6i.png)
![\[ x^2 + 4x - 12 = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/cs2r315z7nm6p5jng4o5x3e6zymi9heu4o.png)
![\[ (x - 3)(x + 4) = 0 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/u7a2oyq9g8udypfojvk2sazsawirswvwjs.png)
![\[ x = 3, -4 \]](https://img.qammunity.org/2024/formulas/mathematics/high-school/cf17gavc3l1wkd94r8idzg00bmsz2r3xhy.png)
The correct solutions are found by applying the Zero Product Property after step 2. Jamal's solution correctly factors the quadratic expression, resulting in the correct roots (x-values).
On the other hand, George's solution has an incorrect factorization, leading to inaccurate roots. Therefore, Jamal's solution is accurate, and George's solution is inaccurate due to an error in factorization.