Question

Which of the following general exceptions are based on the "Special Relationship" of the Public Duty Doctrine?

1) Residents in a home within the city limits
2) Suspect being held at the station
3) Motorist on an Interstate highway
4) All of the above

Answer 1

The option that is based on the 'Special Relationship' of the Public Duty Doctrine is a suspect being held at the station, as there is a specific duty of care to individuals in custody.

Step-by-step explanation:

The general exceptions based on the "Special Relationship" of the Public Duty Doctrine are related to cases where there is a specific, differentiated level of duty to certain individuals as opposed to the general public. This can include situations like a suspect being held at the station where the police have a custodial duty that invokes a special relationship exception.

Potential scenarios of application might refer to a legal obligation police departments have to protect those in their custody, which might not extend to general citizens such as residents in a home within the city limits or a motorist on an Interstate highway in the ordinary course of duty. Therefore, out of the options provided, only the suspect being held at the station clearly falls under a special relationship in the context of the Public Duty Doctrine.