Final answer:
The best indicator of successful periodontal therapy is root surfaces that feel smooth and glass-like, as this indicates healing and absence of inflammation.
Step-by-step explanation:
The BEST evaluative criterion for the success of periodontal therapy is option 1) Root surfaces that feel smooth and glass-like. This tactile characteristic is indicative of successful debridement and the absence of calculus and plaque. Such surfaces suggest that the inflammatory process has been arrested and healing has occurred. Root surfaces that feel smooth and glass-like are contrasted with rough and uneven surfaces, which can harbor bacteria and promote inflammation. Thus, smooth roots are a favorable sign following periodontal therapy and signify a positive outcome.