34.5k views
0 votes
Due Today!!

Based on your impression of Eliza, which ending makes more sense, the book or the movie? Why? Explain your
answer in a short paragraph. Pygmalion.

User Chima
by
8.6k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Ultimately, the choice between the play and the film ending in "My Fair Lady" on individual preferences for narrative closure and romantic resolution versus the open-ended and ambiguous nature of Shaw's original vision.

In "My Fair Lady," both the original play "Pygmalion" by George Bernard Shaw and the musical adaptation have distinct endings. The play concludes with ambiguity, suggesting that Professor Higgins and Eliza might not reunite romantically.

On the other hand, the film adaptation, "My Fair Lady," opts for a more conventional and satisfying conclusion, with Eliza returning to Higgins. The cinematic ending provides a romantic resolution that aligns with audience expectations and the conventions of Hollywood storytelling.

However, the choice between the two depends on one's preference for closure and romantic satisfaction versus the open-endedness of Shaw's original vision.

While the play's ending leaves room for interpretation and societal critique, the movie's conclusion offers a more conventional and emotionally gratifying resolution, catering to the expectations of a broader audience.

Complete question:

My Fair Lady - Based on your impression of Eliza, which ending makes more sense, the book or the movie(My Fair Lady)? Why? Explain your

User Rivenfall
by
7.5k points