Final Answer:
The most effective way to critique John's idea would be "While intriguing, your suggested topic may be too broad for our semester project. Let's consider a more focused aspect to ensure a manageable recommendation report." Option A is the answer.
Step-by-step explanation:
In critiquing John's idea, it is crucial to express the concern about the project's scope without dismissing the topic's intrinsic interest. The true statement acknowledges the allure of the suggested topic while emphasizing the practicality of narrowing down the focus. This approach maintains a positive tone and encourages collaboration in finding a more manageable and achievable aspect of the topic. It promotes effective teamwork by addressing the challenge constructively rather than presenting an outright rejection.
Option A is the answer.
""
Complete Question
You have been assigned to a team in your technical-communication class. Each team must pick a topic for the recommendation report, which is a collaborative project worth a significant part of your semester grade. As you are discussing potential projects, John suggests a topic that is interesting but is too large to complete in the time available in the semester. Which statement represents the most effective way to critique John's idea?
While intriguing, your suggested topic may be too broad for our semester project. Let's consider a more focused aspect to ensure a manageable recommendation report.
Your idea is too complicated, and we won't be able to handle it. Let's choose something easier.
That topic is not interesting enough; let's find something else that will be more engaging for the audience.
I don't think we have the skills to research and write about that topic. Let's pick something simpler that we're more comfortable with.
""