129k views
1 vote
Should Psychogenic Voice Therapy be approached holistically or individually?

User Altandogan
by
8.3k points

1 Answer

7 votes

Final answer:

In treating Psychogenic Voice Disorders, a balance between holistic and individualistic approaches should be taken into account, considering psychological, emotional, and social factors, as well as the patient's unique context. Hypnosis and meditation may be considered after thorough assessment of the patient's condition.

Step-by-step explanation:

Psychogenic Voice Therapy should be approached in a manner that recognizes the individuality of the patient as well as the holistic aspects of treatment. Therapies for psychological-related voice disorders often benefit from considering the whole person, including their emotional, social, and psychological factors, rather than focusing only on the voice as an isolated symptom. The literature suggests the effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapy, as noted by Shedler (2010), which implies a need to address underlying psychological processes. Additionally, consideration of multiple treatment mechanisms, such as hypnosis or meditation, may be explored after thoroughly evaluating the patient's unique context and medical background.

The choice between a holistic approach versus an individualistic approach depends on the specific needs of the patient and the clinical judgment of the therapist. It is essential to gather adequate information about the patient's medical history, psychological profile, and personal preferences when determining the appropriateness of techniques like hypnosis and meditation as complimenting psychological therapy. As per Abbass et al. (2006), short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy has been found to be effective for somatic disorders, reinforcing the need to view therapy as both holistic and considering individual nuances.

User Vuks
by
8.1k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.