198k views
5 votes
What powers have arisen from the Take-care clause?

User Jayeff
by
7.2k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The Take-care clause has given rise to the doctrine of implied powers, enabling Congress to pass laws necessary and proper for executing its delegated powers. The extent of these powers, particularly under the commerce clause, has been both expanded and limited by the Supreme Court. Implied powers include controversial policy areas such as healthcare, where the interplay between federal and state jurisdiction is evident.

Step-by-step explanation:

The powers that have arisen from the Take-care clause are intrinsically linked to the concept of implied powers, which the clause essentially authorized. This clause, coming at the end of Section 8 in the Constitution, allows Congress to enact laws deemed necessary and proper to execute the powers that the Constitution explicitly delegates. One of the most significant uses of this clause was by Alexander Hamilton in his justification for the creation of the Bank of the United States, citing that while not explicitly mentioned, such an institution was necessary for handling the finances of the nation.

However, the extent of the commerce clause has been debated and even rolled back in cases such as United States v. Lopez (1995), where the Supreme Court struck down a federal law as exceeding the powers granted by the commerce clause. The court has been seen to uphold states' rights, limiting Congress's ability to legislate in areas they consider to be within the states' purview. The battle over healthcare policy, like the Affordable Care Act, ties into these issues of federal versus state power, where the federal government's role in providing for the general welfare is weighed against the rights reserved to the states.

Moreover, the supremacy clause further emphasizes that federal laws and treaties made under the authority of the Constitution are the supreme law of the land, taking precedence over state constitutions and laws. This has implications for how conflicts between federal and state regulations are resolved, often favoring the federal government.

User Jahnette
by
8.5k points