Final answer:
The phrase from 'Sister Carrie' that means to surpass others in an unusual way is 'Cherry on Top.' It implies an additional enhancement to something good.
Step-by-step explanation:
The phrase from "Sister Carrie" by Theodore Dreiser that means to surpass all others in an unusual way is D) Cherry on Top. This phrase is used metaphorically to describe something as being an additional enhancement to something that is already considered good or desirable. In "Sister Carrie", the phrase is used in a figurative sense; it does not refer to an actual cherry or dessert but stands for adding an extra level of excellence or perfection to something that is already seen as outstanding.