68.1k views
2 votes
Why was she told that her novel wasn't "authentically African?"

a. She told stories of blond-haired, blue eyed girls and that did not represent those who are "authentically African."


b. Her characters were well- behaved and they respected the government and that was not "authentically African."


c. Her characters were educated and drove cars and therefore were not "authentically African."


d. That her characters were in poverty and did strange rituals and that was not "authentically African."

User Morocklo
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The student's novel was criticized for not being 'authentically African' because it featured educated, middle-class characters who were not in poverty. This critique reflects a narrow view of African authenticity based on stereotypes, neglecting the continent's diverse and authentic experiences that include stories of grounded, educated, and middle-class Africans.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question pertains to the criticism that a novel was not 'authentically African'. This critique implies that the novel did not align with the critic's preconceptions of African authenticity, which may involve certain stereotypes about poverty, lack of education, or other negative depictions. In contrast, the novel presented characters that were educated, middle-class, and did not conform to these narrow views of African life. This situation underscores a challenge that many writers face in representing diverse and authentic experiences that move beyond clichéd narratives and stereotypes.

African authenticity should not be narrowly defined by hardship and suffering or by any single story. Rather, it encompasses a wide range of experiences, including those of the middle-class and educated individuals that are just as authentically African. The critique of the novel being not 'authentically African' because it featured characters who drove cars and were not starving reflects a limited and stereotypical understanding of Africa, one that writers like Chinua Achebe and Camara Laye have challenged in their own works. They, along with other writers, have broadened the narrative, allowing for more diverse representations of African life and identities to be depicted in literature.

Consequently, the critique that the novel is not authentically African because it does not align with stereotypical representations is a flawed notion founded on limited perspectives that fail to acknowledge the rich diversity of African cultures, experiences, and stories.

User AndrewJC
by
8.4k points