230k views
2 votes
Is Juliet's treatment of the Nurse justified? What do you think about her words and her behavior?

A) Yes, Juliet's treatment of the Nurse is justified because the Nurse's advice and actions were inappropriate.
B) No, Juliet's treatment of the Nurse is not justified because the Nurse was only trying to help.
C) It depends on the specific context of their interactions and the Nurse's behavior.
D) I cannot make a judgment without more information about the specific situation.

User Acesmndr
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Final answer:

The treatment of the Nurse by Juliet in Romeo and Juliet can be seen as justified or unjustified depending on the specific context of their interactions and the Nurse's behavior. In some instances, the Nurse provides inappropriate advice and actions that may warrant Juliet's frustration and harsh words. However, it's important to consider that the Nurse is acting out of concern for Juliet's well-being and is trying to help resolve the conflict between Juliet and her family.

Step-by-step explanation:

The treatment of the Nurse by Juliet in Romeo and Juliet can be seen as justified or unjustified depending on the specific context of their interactions and the Nurse's behavior. In some instances, the Nurse provides inappropriate advice and actions that may warrant Juliet's frustration and harsh words. However, it's important to consider that the Nurse is acting out of concern for Juliet's well-being and is trying to help resolve the conflict between Juliet and her family.

For example, in Act 3, Scene 5, Juliet becomes angry with the Nurse for suggesting she marry Paris to avoid her troubles. Juliet's harsh words and behavior in this scene can be seen as justified, as the Nurse's advice goes against Juliet's true feelings and desires to be with Romeo.

On the other hand, in Act 2, Scene 5, the Nurse genuinely supports Juliet's love for Romeo and helps facilitate their secret marriage. In this case, Juliet's treatment of the Nurse would not be justified, as the Nurse is only trying to help and is acting in Juliet's best interest.

User Olivrg
by
9.2k points