Final answer:
Charles Lightoller described the water on the night of the Titanic sinking as 'Like ice,' adhering to historical accounts of the North Atlantic's freezing temperatures.
Step-by-step explanation:
Charles Lightoller was asked by a reporter what the water felt like that night. Among the options provided, (A) Like ice is the answer that corresponds to Lightoller's experience. The descriptions available as references depict water in various settings, consistently emphasizing its coldness in situations related to distress or in contrasting environments like the icy January coast rather than tropical climates. This aligns with the historical context of Lightoller's situation during the sinking of the Titanic, where the North Atlantic waters would have indeed been frigid.