70.2k views
4 votes
The most significant improvements in working conditions for U.S. workers have been won by:

A. Improvements have been won solely through government legislation with no involvement of labor movements or worker advocacy.
B. Improvements have been won primarily through the benevolence of employers without the need for worker activism.
C. Improvements have been won through violent and destructive means without any peaceful or legal strategies.
D. Improvements have been won only in recent years and have not been influenced by the labor movement's historical efforts.

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

Significant improvements in U.S. working conditions are the result of efforts by labor unions, political advocacy, and government legislation throughout history, not solely from any single method mentioned in the given options.

Step-by-step explanation:

The most significant improvements in working conditions for U.S. workers have been a result of multifaceted efforts that include labor movements, political advocacy, government legislation, and sometimes even the actions of employers themselves.

Historically, early labor unions such as the National Labor Union and the Knights of Labor opened their membership to a diverse workforce and fought for workers' rights.

However, due to public reactions against violent strikes, these organizations eventually failed. Successor organizations like the American Federation of Labor continued the efforts, albeit with challenges due to negative publicity.

Ultimately, substantial reforms were realized through government legislation responding to labor protests, setting minimum wages, maximum work hours, prohibiting child labor, and ensuring safe working conditions.

These reforms emerged over time and involved contributions from a variety of stakeholders including workers, labor unions, reformers, and political leaders.

In the end, it is apparent that workers' rights and improvements have not come solely through one avenue but rather through persistent efforts by organized labor, policy makers, and at times even employers, recognizing the benefits of proactive reform.

Therefore, option A, B, and C do not fully capture the complexity of how labor improvements have been achieved in the U.S. Option D also misrepresents the historical impact of the labor movement on current working conditions.

User Raja G
by
8.7k points