157k views
3 votes
Compare the portrayal of Lucy in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to Isabel in the poem Adventures of Isabel concerning standing up for beliefs and perseverance. Which character's approach to standing up for what they believe in or not giving up is more inspiring?

a) Lucy
b) Isabel
c) Both equally
d) Neither

1 Answer

3 votes

Final answer:

Both Lucy and Isabel present inspiring examples of standing up for one's beliefs, with Lucy's subtle sacrificial choice contrasting with Isabel's direct confrontation and resilience.

Step-by-step explanation:

When comparing the portrayal of Lucy from The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to Isabel in the poem Adventures of Isabel, we find two distinctive characters who embody the spirit of standing up for beliefs and perseverance. Lucy is depicted in the narrative as a figure who, through external events and personal sacrifice, reaches a moment of greatness. Her heroic or devilish choice, as the text notes, would have been considered saintly in another time or place, yet in her Virginian context, it's undervalued and largely forgotten. On the other hand, Isabel is a character known for facing her fears directly and overcoming them without ever losing her resolve. Both characters serve as inspiring examples of courage and determination, though their approaches differ significantly because of their contrasting settings and times.

Choosing which character's approach is more inspiring is subjective and ultimately relates to what one finds more admirable or relatable. Lucy's choice is a deep sacrifice for the superhuman or divine, resonating with those who value the silent, fundamental shifts brought about through sacrifice. Meanwhile, Isabel's direct confrontation and unwavering spirit might inspire those who favor active resistance against challenges.

If I were to make a recommendation, it would be c) Both equally, because inspiration can be drawn from both characters' resilience and their different forms of standing up for their beliefs.

User Haswin
by
8.1k points