Question

Which of the following scenarios supports the argument that nurture shapes behavior?

a. Logan and his twin sister were raised by positive, affirming parents. Logan, however, suffered from attention deficit disorder, which is more common among men, while his sister did not.
b. Joshua has been diagnosed with skin cancer, but none of his sisters have been.
c. Susan's sense of smell was far more acute than her husband's, enabling her to be able to tell what seasoning her food needed without tasting it.
d. Evelyn, like all the women in her family, outlived her husband.
e. Benjie's father, an alcoholic, suffered from liver damage. He advised his son from a young age to avoid such destructive habits, and Benjie grew up to have a healthy lifestyle.

Answer 1

The scenario where Benjie adopts a healthy lifestyle despite his father's alcoholism illustrates that nurture shapes behavior, underlining the influence of parenting and environment.

Step-by-step explanation:

Scenario Supporting the Argument that Nurture Shapes Behavior

The scenario that supports the argument that nurture shapes behavior is:

(e) Benjie's father, an alcoholic, suffered from liver damage. He advised his son from a young age to avoid such destructive habits, and Benjie grew up to have a healthy lifestyle.

This example illustrates how environmental influence, specifically the advice and guidance of a parent, can lead to the development of personal behaviors, supporting the nurture side of the nature versus nurture debate. Despite his father's history of alcoholism, Benjie was able to adopt a healthy lifestyle based on the nurturance and advice given to him. This suggests that the behaviors we learn from our environment can have a significant impact on our life decisions and health practices.