Final answer:
There are several reasons to help Native Americans, including addressing historical injustices, fulfilling treaty obligations, reducing disparities, preserving culture, and fulfilling moral responsibility. However, there are also arguments against helping Native Americans, including limited resources, self-reliance, individual responsibility, sovereignty concerns, and potential misuse of funds.
Step-by-step explanation:
When it comes to helping Native Americans, there are several reasons why it is important to do so:
- Historical injustices: Native Americans have faced centuries of oppression and mistreatment, including forced removal from their lands and the destruction of their cultures. Helping them is a way to acknowledge and address these past injustices.
- Treaty obligations: The United States has entered into treaties with Native American tribes, promising to provide certain services and assistance. It is important to honor these obligations.
- Poverty and disparities: Native Americans continue to face high levels of poverty, unemployment, and health disparities. Helping them can address these inequalities and improve their quality of life.
- Preservation of culture: Native American cultures are rich and valuable, but they are at risk of being eroded due to historical and ongoing assimilation efforts. Helping Native Americans can support the preservation and revitalization of their cultures.
- Moral responsibility: As a society, we have a moral responsibility to help those who have been marginalized and oppressed. Helping Native Americans is a way to fulfill this responsibility.
On the other hand, there are some arguments against helping Native Americans:
- Limited resources: Some people argue that resources should be allocated to other pressing issues rather than specifically focusing on Native Americans.
- Self-reliance: There is a belief that Native Americans should work towards self-reliance and not depend on external assistance.
- Individual responsibility: Some argue that individuals should take responsibility for their own lives and circumstances, rather than relying on assistance.
- Sovereignty: The issue of tribal sovereignty and self-governance can be complex. Some argue that the focus should be on supporting tribes' self-governance rather than providing assistance.
- Misuse of funds: There are concerns that aid provided to Native Americans may not always be used effectively or efficiently.