Final answer:
To evaluate CAPM using annual data on portfolios sorted by CAPM beta, compute the average return, volatility, average beta, and Sharpe ratio for each portfolio.
Step-by-step explanation:
In order to evaluate CAPM using annual data on portfolios sorted by CAPM beta, you will need to compute the average return, volatility, average beta, and Sharpe ratio for each portfolio. This will allow you to assess the performance and risk-adjusted returns of each portfolio.
As a mean-variance investor, you would choose the portfolio that offers the highest Sharpe ratio. The Sharpe ratio measures the excess return per unit of risk, so a higher Sharpe ratio indicates a better risk-adjusted return.
To show that CAPM does not hold, you can plot the security market line (SML) along with the average returns and average betas of the portfolios. If the average returns and average betas do not align with the SML, it suggests that the expected return and beta relationship predicted by CAPM is not accurate.
In terms of mispricing under the assumption that CAPM is the right model, portfolios that have higher expected returns than predicted by their betas would be considered underpriced, while portfolios with lower expected returns than predicted by their betas would be considered overpriced.