133k views
3 votes
When two variables, X and Y, are correlated, what are the possible directions of

causality?
(A) X could be causing Y
(B) Y could be causing X
(C) Some third factor could be causing both X and Y
(D) All of these the following would indicate physiological​

User Gutenberg
by
8.9k points

1 Answer

4 votes

Final answer:

The possible directions of causality when variables X and Y are correlated include X causing Y, Y causing X, and a third factor causing both, with all options being possible since correlation does not necessarily imply causation.

Step-by-step explanation:

When two variables, X and Y, are correlated, the possible directions of causality are:

  1. X could be causing Y - meaning X is the independent variable influencing the dependent variable Y.
  2. Y could be causing X - here, Y would be considered the independent variable affecting X.
  3. Some third factor could be causing both X and Y - this is an instance where a confounding variable is responsible for the observed changes in both variables.
  4. All of these options are possible, underscoring that correlation does not necessarily imply causation.

These possibilities highlight the importance of conducting thorough research to determine if there is a causal relationship rather than simply relying on correlation.

User Platon
by
7.6k points