31.2k views
5 votes
What would have happened to Gabe if Jonas stayed in the community?

User Gokujou
by
8.2k points

1 Answer

2 votes

Final answer:

If Jonas had stayed in the community in 'The Giver,' Gabe would have likely been released due to his failure to meet the community's standards. Jonas's departure triggers disruption, suggesting a different fate for Gabe.

Step-by-step explanation:

The question deals with the outcome for the character Gabe if Jonas had stayed in the community, based on the book The Giver by Lois Lowry. If Jonas had stayed in the community, it is implied that Gabe, being classified as a weaker infant, would have been subjected to release, which in the context of the community means euthanasia. The community in the novel values sameness and conformity and does not tolerate those who do not meet its standards of normalcy, which places Gabe at risk due to his developmental issues.

However, with Jonas's escape at the end of the novel, he indirectly disrupts the community's strict control and potentially creates a new path for its members, including Gabe. If Jonas had not left, Gabe would have likely faced release because he was not considered to be progressing at the same rate as other children. Jonas's connection with Gabe, especially his intent to save the child by leaving, highlights the themes of individuality, choice, and love that are central to the narrative.

User Pbatey
by
8.2k points